Table of Contents

If you’ve ever pulled a slice of leftover pizza from the fridge only to reheat it in the microwave and end up with a soggy, sad piece of bread topped with rubbery cheese—you’re not alone. Countless Americans struggle with the correct way to revive leftover pizza. However, there’s one method that consistently delivers crispiness, even heating, and a flavor that rivals a fresh pie: reheat pizza in an air fryer. “Check today’s price on Amazon”

Today, Americans love convenience, speed, and quality—especially when it comes to food. With air fryers becoming one of the fastest-growing kitchen gadgets in the U.S., it’s no surprise that more people are turning to these compact appliances to bring their pizza back to life. And honestly? Once you try reheating pizza in an air fryer, you’ll never go back to microwaving again.

In this comprehensive guide, you’ll learn:

• Why air fryers are the best method for reheating pizza
• Step-by-step instructions for different pizza types
• Expert tips for restaurant-quality results
• Best air fryers on Amazon for reheating pizza
• Troubleshooting common issues
• Creative ways to use reheated pizza
• And much more!

Let’s dive into the world of crispy pizza perfection.

Why Reheating Pizza in an Air Fryer Works Better Than Any Other Method

If you’re wondering why this method has gone viral across U.S. households, the science is simple. Pizza crust becomes soggy in the microwave because microwaves heat moisture unevenly. The oven, on the other hand, dries the pizza out unless you monitor it constantly. But the air fryer? It strikes the perfect balance.

1. Air fryers circulate hot air rapidly

This mimics the effect of a professional pizza oven but in a smaller, more controlled space. As a result, your pizza heats evenly while restoring that crisp, satisfying crunch.

2. You get results in under 4 minutes

Americans love speed. Instead of waiting 15–20 minutes for a conventional oven, your air fryer reheats pizza in less than half the time.

3. The cheese melts without becoming rubbery

Rapid heating means the cheese regains its gooey, stretchy texture instead of becoming stiff.

4. Air fryers preserve flavor

Instead of tasting “leftover,” the pizza tastes freshly baked.

5. Works for all pizza types

From thin crust to deep dish to Detroit-style, the air fryer handles them all exceptionally well.

Simply put, if you reheat pizza in an air fryer, you get the closest thing to freshly delivered pizza right from your kitchen counter.

How to Reheat Pizza in an Air Fryer (Step-by-Step for the Perfect Slice)

Let’s break down exactly how to get the perfect reheated slice.

Step 1: Preheat Your Air Fryer

Although not strictly required, preheating significantly improves crispiness.
Recommended temperature: 350°F (175°C)

Most air fryers in the U.S. take 2–3 minutes to preheat.

Step 2: Prepare Your Pizza

Place the slice(s) in a single layer. Do NOT stack them. Stacking traps moisture and ruins texture.

If your pizza has lots of toppings, press them gently so nothing flies off due to the air circulation.

Step 3: Reheat

Time depends on the crust thickness:

Pizza Type	Temperature	Time
Thin Crust	350°F	2–3 minutes
Regular Crust	350°F	3–4 minutes
Deep Dish	350–375°F	5–6 minutes
Detroit Style	375°F	4–5 minutes

Check halfway through to avoid over-crisping.

Step 4: Enjoy Immediately

Air-fried pizza retains heat well but is still best eaten hot.

Reheating Different Types of Pizza in an Air Fryer (Extended Guide)

Different pizzas behave differently when reheated. Here’s how to get the best results for each.

1. Thin-Crust Pizza

Thin crust can easily burn if overheated.
Use 325–350°F with a shorter cook time.
This keeps the crust light, crisp, and not overly brittle.

2. New York-Style Pizza

America’s favorite slice reheats beautifully in an air fryer.
The crust becomes crisp while the center stays soft and stretchy.

3. Deep-Dish Pizza

Because of the thicker, doughier base, deep dish needs extra time.
Start at 350°F for 4 minutes, then check.
Increase time in 1-minute increments.

4. Sicilian or Detroit-Style Pizza

These square pizzas benefit from slightly higher heat (375°F).
The caramelized cheese edges become irresistible in an air fryer.

5. Gluten-Free Pizza

Gluten-free dough can become too hard in high heat.
Lower temperature to 325°F and reheat slowly.

Air Fryer Safety Tips for Reheating Pizza

To ensure the best experience (Reheat Pizza in an Air Fryer):

• Do not use foil unless your air fryer manual allows it
  Some brands warn against blocking airflow.
• Avoid reheating greasy pizzas without a liner
  This prevents smoking.
• Never overcrowd the basket
  Airflow is crucial.
• Watch the first batch carefully
  Every air fryer model reheats slightly differently.

Expert Tricks for Restaurant-Quality Reheated Pizza

To take things to the next level:

Add a splash of water—away from the pizza

Placing a few drops in the drawer adds humidity that keeps cheese gooey.

Use parchment paper liners

These prevent sticking and make cleanup easy.

Spray a light mist of oil on the crust

It refreshes the crispiness beautifully.

Add fresh toppings after reheating

Basil, grated parmesan, chili flakes—anything works.

Reheat pizza with garlic butter

Brushing the crust boosts flavor dramatically.

Best Air Fryers on Amazon for Reheating Pizza

Below are high-converting, highly rated air fryers American shoppers love.
These are great for your affiliate marketing earnings.

1. Ninja AF101 Air Fryer — Best Overall for Reheating Pizza

Amazon Link: “Check today’s price on Amazon”

Why it’s perfect:

• Heats evenly
• Large basket fits 2–3 slices
• Reliable, durable, and highly popular

This is one of America’s top-selling air fryers.

COSORI Pro LE 5-Quart Air Fryer — Best Value

Search COSORI Pro LE Air Fryer on Amazon.

Why U.S. customers love it:

• Fast preheat
• Quiet
• Super crispy results

COSORI is a favorite among home cooks.

Instant Vortex 6QT Air Fryer — Best for Families

Search Instant Vortex Air Fryer on Amazon.

Why it stands out:

• Fits multiple slices
• Smart controls
• Excellent for thick-crust reheating

Perfect for family pizza nights.

Ninja Foodi 2-Basket Air Fryer — Best for Variety

Search Ninja Foodi DualZone on Amazon.

Why it’s great:

• Reheat two types of pizza at once
• Independent temperature controls
• Highly efficient

Ideal for mixed pizza preferences.

CHEFMAN TurboFry — Best Budget Option

Search Chefman Turbofry on Amazon.

Why it’s popular:

• Affordable
• Compact
• Great for college students or small kitchens

Perfect for reheating pizza in dorms or apartments.

Troubleshooting: Why Your Pizza Didn’t Reheat Correctly

Even with air fryers, issues can happen. Here’s how to fix them.

Problem: Pizza is too hard

Solution:

• Lower the temperature
• Add 1–2 drops of water to the bottom tray

Problem: Cheese burned

Solution:

• Reduce time
• Use 320–330°F

Problem: Crust still feels soggy

Solution:

• Increase temperature by 10–20 degrees
• Try reheating 1 slice at a time

Problem: Toppings fly off

Solution:

• Gently press toppings before reheating
• Use a mesh rack if available

Creative Ways to Use Reheated Pizza

Reheated pizza doesn’t have to be boring. Try these:

Pizza Croutons

Cut slices into squares and air fry until crunchy.
Perfect for salads or soups.

Pizza Breakfast Sandwich

Use two pizza slices as buns.
Add egg or sausage in between.

Pizza Fries

Slice pizza into strips and air fry until crisp.

Pizza Nachos

Tear pieces of pizza, layer with cheese, pepperoni, jalapeños, and air fry.

Why Air Fryers Are a Must-Have Kitchen Gadget in the USA

Americans value efficiency, speed, and versatility. Air fryers deliver exactly that:

• Perfect for busy schedules
• Ideal for students, parents, workers, and seniors
• Safer than deep frying
• Energy efficient compared to ovens
• Great for reheating—not just cooking

When you reheat pizza in an air fryer, you’re embracing a modern, smarter kitchen lifestyle.

Top Reasons Americans Prefer Reheating Pizza in an Air Fryer

✔ Speed

No waiting for ovens to heat up.

✔ Consistency

Every slice reheats evenly.

✔ Better Texture

Crisp crust + melted cheese = winning combo.

✔ Works with any pizza brand

Domino’s, Papa John’s, Pizza Hut, Little Caesars—you name it.

✔ Perfect for frozen pizza too

Air fryers revive frozen slices incredibly well.

Pair Your Reheated Pizza With These American Favorites

To elevate your pizza night:

• Ranch dressing
• Garlic parmesan dip
• Buffalo sauce
• Chop salad
• Mozzarella sticks
• Air-fried chicken wings

All complement the air-fried reheated slice beautifully.

A Better Way to Enjoy Leftover Pizza (Final Thoughts)

If you’ve ever wondered how to make leftover pizza taste fresh again, now you know: reheat pizza in an air fryer. This method is fast, efficient, and produces restaurant-quality results right at home. As air fryers continue to dominate U.S. kitchens, it’s no surprise Americans prefer this technique over traditional reheating methods.

Whether you have thin crust, deep dish, New York-style, or gourmet pizza, the air fryer brings out the best texture, flavor, and aroma. It’s the easiest way to transform leftovers into a brand-new meal you’ll genuinely enjoy.

And remember—choosing the right air fryer can elevate your experience even further. The recommended Amazon products above are ideal for anyone looking to upgrade their kitchen, improve convenience, and enjoy better-tasting food. Reheat Pizza in an Air Fryer

FAQ: Reheat Pizza in an Air Fryer

1. Can I reheat frozen pizza in an air fryer?

Yes! Air fry at 350°F for 5–7 minutes. No need to thaw.

2. Can I stack pizzas in the air fryer?

No. You should always place slices in a single layer.

3. Can I use foil in my air fryer?

Only if your model allows it. Check the manual.

4. What is the best temp for reheating pizza?

350°F is the sweet spot for most pizza types.

5. Will my pizza dry out?

Not if you monitor the time and avoid overheating.

6. Do air fryers use a lot of electricity?

No. They are more energy-efficient than ovens.

7. Is it safe for kids to use an air fryer?

Yes, with supervision. They are safer than ovens or stovetops.

8. Which air fryer is best for reheating pizza?

The Ninja AF101 and COSORI Pro LE are top-rated in the USA.